B.C.’s premier best fiscal manager, Ontario’s worst: Study
October 25th, 2010OTTAWA — B.C. Premier Gordon Campbell ranks No. 1 in terms of dealing with fiscal policy whereas Dalton McGuinty, premier of Ontario, is the weakest, according to an analysis conducted by the Fraser Institute think-tank released Monday.
Further, the study’s authors suggest premiers from Western Canada tend to be better fiscal managers than their counterparts in central and Eastern Canada.
“Of the 10 premiers we examined, Premier Campbell simply did a better job than the others of managing his province’s public finances and pursuing sound long-term economic policies,” said Niels Veldhuis, Fraser Institute’s senior economist and co-author of analysis.
“Given the size of Ontario’s economy, the last-place ranking of McGuinty is particularly alarming. The lesson here is that McGuinty should follow Premier Campbell’s lead and stick to prudent spending increases, lower taxes, and surplus budgets.”
The Ontario government has mapped a slow road to balancing the province’s books. It has projected a deficit of $19.7 billion for fiscal year 2010-11, and would remain in the red until 2017-18.
Meanwhile, British Columbia recently announced its deficit for the present fiscal year would be slightly smaller than previously projected, coming in at $1.4 billion. British Columbia anticipates returning to budget surplus in the 2013-14 fiscal year.
The Fraser Institute examined the relative fiscal performance of 10 Canadian premiers for the duration of their time in office up to the most recent year of available data, which was the 2009-10 fiscal year. Each premier received an overall score out of 100, based on their performance on three components: government spending, taxes, and debt and deficits.
Campbell was first overall with a score of 89.1. Former Manitoba premier Gary Doer ranked second, 78.2, followed by Danny Williams of Newfoundland and Labrador, at 71.0. Fourth and fifth place went to Alberta’s Ed Stelmach, 66.4, and Saskatchewan’s Brad Wall, 57.9 — and as a result western Canadian premiers clinched four of the top five spots in the overall rankings.
By Paul Vieira, Financial Post
Link to full article